Innovative ideas for direct mail campaigns that work at volume

Innovation in direct mail usually comes down to format and finish rather than a clever new concept. A textured envelope, an unusual shape or a personalised image can make a mailer stand out before it’s opened and each of these choices can be scaled to suit a run of 5,000 or 50,000 items.

This guide looks at what’s achievable, what it costs relative to a standard mailing and how to test an idea before committing to the full run.

What are some innovative ideas for direct mail campaigns?

This is about physical execution rather than targeting or messaging, focussing on formats, finishes and fulfilment.

Paper wrap

Paper wrap works well for magazines, brochures and multi-item packs and becomes more economical than envelopes as volume increases. It also acts as a blank canvas for full-colour print and A5 items under 100g can unlock postage discounts through Mailmark® that aren’t available for A5 polywrapped mail.

Tactile finishes

Spot gloss UV varnish, matt lamination, soft-touch lamination and gloss lamination all add a physical layer that a screen can’t replicate. Soft-touch works particularly well for a premium feel, while gloss suits photography-led designs.

Die-cut and unusual formats

Cutting a mailer into a custom shape rather than a standard rectangle creates a one-piece self-mailer that’s hard to ignore. It needs a bigger budget than standard print and machine fulfilment requires at least two straight edges for the equipment to grip. This means highly irregular shapes may need hand fulfilment instead.

Personalised imagery

Beyond a name, variable data printing can tailor images and copy to the recipient, which tends to lift engagement more than text personalisation alone.

QR codes and PURLs

QR codes and personalised URLs (PURLs) give a physical mailer a direct route into a trackable digital response, whether that’s a landing page or a personalised offer.

Inserts

You can also give readers more to explore by adding a second or third item into a pack without changing the core format. Inserts can include vouchers, brochures or a personalised note to the reader.

Innovative direct mail costs relative to a standard mailing

None of these ideas needs to break the budget, but each carries a trade-off. Colour image printing could add to the lead time compared with standard envelope printing, which can be done at high speed using inkjet printing instead of laser printing. Die-cut formats cost more to produce than a standard rectangle.

The additional costs shouldn’t deter you from using innovative bulk mail services, but inspire you to use them where they have the most impact.

What’s achievable at volume and what isn’t

Machine enclosing runs at roughly 40 times the speed of hand fulfilment, which is why straight-edged, standard formats are the most cost-effective choice at scale.

If you’re planning on using more than ten items per envelope, hand fulfilment takes over, as machines can only enclose up to ten items per envelope. Peel-and-seal envelopes give a premium personal feel to a campaign, but can’t be machine sealed. This means they will always incur hand fulfilment costs and take longer to complete.

Above 10,000 items, spot sealing lets litho printing and personalisation work together, combining litho’s lower unit cost with a still-personal touch.

Test before you commit to the full run

Before scaling a new format or finish across a full run, it’s worth trialling it on a smaller batch first. It is costly, so it only makes sense for large scale campaigns to help confirm the finish behaves as expected in production and gives a read on response before the larger spend is committed.

Whatever combination of formats and finishes you’re considering, our bulk mailing services are built to handle it at scale. Contact us and we’ll help you plan your stand out campaign.

Need help?

Work with a proven partner for print, mail and fulfilment. We do everything in-house, so projects stay on schedule and campaigns run smoothly from start to finish.

Learn more